Connect with us

Dodger Baseball

Who Is the Genius, Andrew Friedman or Farhan Zaidi?

First of all, let me be clear that I believe that both Andrew Friedman and Farhan Zaidi are the top two genius baseball executives in all of MLB.  However, IMO, AF was getting the lion’s share of the credit while they were teamed together from 2015 through 2018.  We continually read about how Friedman excels at finding gems from the scrap heaps.  JT does not count as he was signed during the Ned Colletti regime.  The three that come to mind during the Andrew Friedman regime are CT3, Max Muncy, and Andrew Toles.  Including JT, the Dodgers have been very fortunate with finding such gems.  But who should get the credit?

Farhan Zaidi orchestrated the CT3 for Zach Lee trade (although I am sure AF approved it).  Muncy was with Zaidi in Oakland, and Farhan was very familiar with him.  Gabe Kapler was the chief reason behind the signing of Toles, and AF has properly credited Gabe.  Again, AF is the President of Baseball Operations, so he does get credit.  However, he was not the driving force behind any of those three.

Now look at what Zaidi has done since he arrived in SF.  He traded for Mike Yastrzemski.  Signed Donovan Solano.  Signed Darin Ruf.  Signed Kevin Gausman.  Signed Alex Wood.  Traded for LaMonte Wade Jr.  Signed Anthony DeSclafani.  Signed Wilmer Flores.  Traded for Alex Dickerson (who had a very good 2019 and 2020 stint with SF).  None of those players were considered front line regulars, and three were previously in the Dodgers organization.  Zaidi put together an aging rag tag team that won 107 games in 2021.  While AF put together a star-studded roster, with a $285MM payroll, that won 106 games.  They were the top two teams in MLB in terms of WL, but they were world’s apart from how their respective teams were built.

Contrarily since 2019, AF has acquired; Tyler White, Jedd Gyorko, Kristopher Negron, Terrance Gore, Billy McKinney, Sheldon Neuse, Steven Souza Jr., Yoshi Tsutsugo, Andy Burns…certainly not the depth we were led to believe in the LAD organization.  And not one of them put up numbers comparable to Alex Dickerson, much less Yaz, Solano, Ruf, Wade, or Flores.  However, Andrew should get credit for signing Albert Pujols.  The best bench bat LAD acquired in the last several years was David Freese, also traded for by Zaidi in 2018.  Where AF did excel was recognizing he needed an elite player in the field, orchestrated the Mookie Betts trade, and signed him to a 12 year $365MM extension.  IMO he also gets credit for the Max Scherzer/Trea Turner trade.  Some did not like the trade.  I thought it was brilliant.  Without Scherzer and Turner, the Dodgers do not go on that 43-13 post trade run.  Without Scherzer do they beat St. Louis in the Wild Card game?  The idea is to win when you have the chance.  Now will AF be able to extend Trea as he did Mookie?  That will go a long way to determine if the trade turns out well or not for LAD.  TT should cost at least as much as Corey Seager.  Not what Seager was offered by AF, but what Texas paid for him.

AF also signed what could turn out to be one of the worst decisions he could have made by signing Trevor Bauer.  Bauer had a career half year in 2020, and still had a career ERA north of 4.00.  On July 28, 2019, Bauer arrogantly showed up his manager and teammates in a game vs. KC. When Terry Francona came to pull Bauer, Bauer turned to face CF and threw the ball into the stands.  He was traded to Cincinnati the next day.   Bauer is a narcissistic egotist that leveraged eleven 2020 starts into a three year $102MM contract.  IMO, this was an AF overreach reaction to what NYM and SD Padres were doing.

With respect to his current Administrative Leave, I heartily acknowledge that per the LA District Attorney, Bauer did nothing criminal, and that at the very least his sexual exploits started out consensual.  I may very well be in the minority of Dodger fans (and that is okay), however, IMO, he is not worthy of wearing the vaunted LAD jersey, one of the most prestigious jerseys in all of sports.  I also believe he will be in the rotation for the Dodgers at some point this season.  Check the YouTube video below, and ask yourself if this is a person who holds himself above the team.


Back to Andrew.  AF did get Max and TT at the trade deadline, but ignored the bench.  Atlanta had struggled most of the year due to their own serious injuries to major players: Mike Soroka, Ronald Acuña Jr, and Marcell Ozuna.  The Braves did have a breakout year from one of their own, 24-year-old 3B Austin Riley.  But their season turned when Alex Anthopoulos orchestrated trades for Joc Pederson, Adam Duvall, Eddie Rosario, and Jorge Soler.  None of whom cost the Braves much at all in terms of prospect capital.  Rosario became the MVP in the NLCS, and Soler was the WS MVP.  AF chose to go with the LAD AAAA talent, and paid the price.

This year, AF signed Andrew Heaney.  Heaney has a career 4.72 ERA.  He was basically given away by the uber pitcher talented LAA 🤦‍♂️ (sarcasm alert) to a NYY team starving for starting pitching.  Why did AF sign him?  We are led to believe that the Dodgers have this tremendous developmental staff that can turn a suspect pitcher into a CY candidate.  Really?!?!  Name the last pitcher LAD has signed FA, or picked up off of waivers, that was “fixed” by this miracle developmental team?  Brett Anderson? Brandon McCarthy? Scott Kazmir?  I can argue for Brandon Morrow.  However, Brandon was yet another failed starting pitcher who was outstanding coming out of the bullpen. He looked great in relief in 2016 with the Pads, and I was ecstatic the Dodgers signed him.  I was a lonely voice pushing for LAD to bring him up before June 1, 2017 the drop-dead date of recalling him or losing him.

So Andrew Heaney will be different?  Maybe yes.  I sure hope so, but the Dodgers DO NOT have a good track record of “fixing” this type of starting pitcher.  The Giants did far better with Gausman and DeSclafani.  The Blue Jays did better with Robbie Ray and Steven Matz.

The Dodger development “fix it” staff will have a great chance to prove themselves as the season progresses.  Besides Heaney, the group will get a chance to “fix”, fellow starting pitchers, Tyler Anderson, and MiLB pitchers Jon Duplantier and Robbie Erlin, as well as MiLB relievers Carson Fulmer and Sam Gaviglio.  Or the 15 pitchers signed from the 2021 draft. Or how about simply resurrecting David Price?  If they can get a good year out of one of the starters and one of the relievers they signed to a MiLB contract, the development staff would prove to be outstanding.

While Zaidi is building his current team as he apparently did with the Dodgers, with the signing of Freddie Freeman, Andrew is proving to be an outstanding BIG MARKET baseball executive.  According to Cots Contracts, the Dodgers incurred a $32,649,965 tax bill on a $285,599,944 2021 payroll.  For 2022, they currently sit at $298,870,834.   Just how sustainable is that payroll level?

In summary, both Friedman and Zaidi are brilliant at what they do.  None better.  They have different tools to work with, but both are adept at creating a great 40-man roster for the regular season.  Now let’s see if AF can bring home a second WS Championship before Zaidi wins his first.

Finally, how will the promotion of Brandon Gomes to Dodgers GM impact Andrew Friedman?  It will be interesting to see how Gomes approaches roster construction.  Will he be like Farhan Zaidi or the current Big Market Andrew Friedman?



Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I think Zaidi is the better talent evaluator. But AF has built and sustained a highly ranked prospect pool, especially young pitching, even though drafting at the end of the draft each year. Even with a monster payroll you need that infusion of young talent to balance out the roster. We will see how Farhan does with his prospects over the next few years.

Michael Norris

Excellent stuff Jeff. I have honestly been frustrated at times because it seems Freidman takes forever to address weaknesses in the team. I thought the bench was an issue early last year, and he kept bringing in guys like Souza and AAAA players. Pujols was their best bench guy last year, and at his age, he outperformed and generated more excitement than any other player AF brought in until Scherzer and Turner. I think sometimes he waits too long to make a move. I do not think they are as deep as they think they are. None of their premier prospects seem to be MLB ready. If anyone on the present roster goes down this season with an injury, they will probably be replaced on the roster by another of his retreads.

Singing the Blue

Maybe Farhan’s major ability is finding underappreciated players who then become real contributors and Andrew’s major ability is finding good executives. I think I read somewhere the other day that the vast majority of playoff teams in 2021 were headed by people from the Andrew Friedman tree.


The Dodgers have said they won’t off an extension to Turner at this time. Suggests that they want to see h whether Lux is the long term solution at SS. Guess we’ll see how that all plays out

Interestingly, the Nations offered Soto something on the order of 325 million over 10 years and he turned it down. Some say he’s asking for a Trout type contract. Hard to believe one would turn down that kind of money. I suspect a lot of the contract was deferred.

Fred Vogel

Both men are excellent judges of talent. Farhan needed to make more personnel changes than AF and did well as all the stars aligned last season for SF. We’ll see how things play out this season. I do believe that Gomes will bring a fresh approach to LA.


I was one of several Dodger fans frustrated by the constant roster churn when Zaidi was the GM. You can’t argue with results though. You move through enough ore and you find a nugget once in a while. He has done the same thing with SF and it has worked brilliantly.

I agree with Michael Norris that the Dodgers have been slow to address needs at times, but this was true when Zaidi was GM as well. In 2016, the Dodgers waited to address needs in the rotation and by the time that they did, Scott Kazmir was the only free agent pitcher left. I think that they consider so many options that they are at times slow to react.

The real genius of Andrew Friedman has been to build a great organization. The last that I heard, the Dodgers had more folks in their analytics department than any other team. Their player development track record has been second to none. Their coaches have done a superior job in coaxing performance out of people of whom it was not expected.

The Dodgers have suffered from a bit of a brain drain as well. Zaidi and Kappler to SF; Anthopolous to Atl, Chris Woodward to Tex, – the list goes on.

The point is that we’ll see if Zaidi is Friedman’s equal in assembling an entire organization

Brad Scott

@JeffDominique: There’s not much evidence to support calling Friedman and Zaidi the top two execs in MLB (that’s especially true of the vastly overrated Zaidi). And throwing around a word like “genius” – especially in the case of Zaidi – is way over the top … he hasn’t done anything even remotely close to earning that sort of accolade. Friedman’s made some good moves, the best of which is adding Betts to an already-strong team … he’s also blundered, including letting Bellinger go. IMHO the Giants’ Brian Sabean and the Braves’ Alex Anthopoulos are the two best front-office talents in MLB, with Sabean’s track record as GM (3 WS titles in 5 seasons) qualifying him more than anyone as a baseball genius.

Must See

More in Dodger Baseball

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x